From collection Ludwig von Mises Collection
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/48717/487179f6630532c2b703872ec1b4e930582351dc" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_015.jpg"
Page 1
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ed198/ed19895178061fce83cc4f4174b66bf876bcd1a7" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_016.jpg"
Page 2
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5007f/5007f889bb1e3e47a25fae0b727c277324bcd777" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_017.jpg"
Page 3
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aeda4/aeda480398c1209668df02c82b3984f3956bf3d3" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_018.jpg"
Page 4
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/df25a/df25abf0780bf0e00f06a669a62385d9553975fd" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_019.jpg"
Page 5
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0d72f/0d72f99d58c1907f53a037a2e2341582c89b2f59" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_020.jpg"
Page 6
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a7d59/a7d59e6cbecbf26bf2aeb78d941cac774b500133" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_021.jpg"
Page 7
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/72ac7/72ac78bf8b22472167be916d3ec07aace218ec6d" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_022.jpg"
Page 8
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/375f1/375f13982fa61db56efede192ae7f26aa6a6dc94" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_023.jpg"
Page 9
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2f752/2f7523a44618aff9a9eef391149c643c0cbc529e" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_024.jpg"
Page 10
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/49cab/49cabd78341a86d015674119e2367d7dbdfa4e31" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_025.jpg"
Page 11
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2c84a/2c84a2e7ad9204e47ca5dc89f8f6e14afd1edb01" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_026.jpg"
Page 12
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ef55c/ef55c8926a006946e8170c6b1a1742601e9fcfce" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_027.jpg"
Page 13
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/350b7/350b77c3f62a4a93d1f4647ad7071a40d8533173" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_028.jpg"
Page 14
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/44940/4494093f3531da06549f05626f2a1b2c79793bf6" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_029.jpg"
Page 15
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e64c2/e64c2b9884f55fae94fa47b0f28c8561472197c4" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_030.jpg"
Page 16
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/86bac/86bac0578730adc6db87280681bbf2df5d556621" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_031.jpg"
Page 17
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/efbcf/efbcf3722e86f555c6a96902204eabec96621310" alt="Grove_von Mises_Box 7_F03_032.jpg"
Page 18
Search
results in pages
Metadata
The American Conservative Character
THE AMERICAN CONSERVATIVE CHARACTER
by
RUSSELL KIRK
(Principal remarks delivered September 27th, 1954 at Yale Law School, being the
first in a series of Lectures on "The Role of the Conservative in Today's World"
sponsored by The Conservative Society of Yale Law School, a student organization.)
"Conservatism is the negation of ideology," Mr. H. Stuart Hughes wrote
more than three years ago, in an article concerned with the decline of political
ideology in Europe. This is quite true. Where ideology seizes upon a nation's
consciousness, the influence of true conservatism declines; and where the power
of ideology declines, there conservatism has opportunity for appealing anew to
men's minds; and appeal to them it must, with all the intelligence at its com-
mand, if it is to save them from apathy or from nihilism. I think, then, that
our country, like most of western Europe, is drifting away from ideology, and
that here, as beyond the oceans, only an elevated conservatism can avert that
bored indifference to past and future, and that destructive contempt for all
moral values, which work the ruin of order.
Napoleon, who detested the doctrinaire reformer, gave us the words,
"ideology" and "ideologist" as terms of abuse; old John Adams was driven nearly
to distraction by "ideology", writing of it, "Our English words, Idiocy or
Idiotism, express not the meaning or force of it. It is presumed its proper
definition is the science of Idiocy. And a very profound, abstruse, and mysteri-
ous science it is. You must descend deeper than the divers in the Dunciad to make
any discoveries, and after all you will find no bottom. It is the bathos, the
theory, the art, the skill of diving and sinking in government. Burke, writing
before the word "ideology"? was coined, employed the word "abstraction" to de-
scribe the ideological approach to politics; and he detested this quite as
heartily as Adams did. In the conservative's opinion, the ideologue is a being
suffering from the delusion that his rigid closet-philosophy contains all the
answers to all the problems of humanity. We have but to be governed by his
rules, the ideologue thinks, and the terrestrial paradise is ours. The ideo-
logue may be an a priori thinker, or an a posteriori thinker, but in his system
no room is left for Providence, or chance, or free will, or prudence. He is
the devotee, often, of what Burke called "ian armed doctrine."
Now the conservative believes that the individual is foolish, although
the species is wise; therefore, unlike the confident ideologue, he declines
to undertake the reconstruction of society and human nature upon the scanty
capital of his private stock of reason. The conservative believes that the
world is not perfectible, and that we poor fallen human creatures, here below,
are not made for happiness, and will not find happiness - at least, not if we
deliberately pursue it; therefore, unlike the ideologue, he is not inclined
to believe that any single fixed system of political concepts can bring justice
and peace and liberty to all men everywhere, if uniformly applied. Conservatism
does not breed fanatics. It does not try to excite the enthusiasm of a secular
religion. If you want men who will sacrifice their past and present and future
to a set of abstract notions, then you must go to Communism, or Fascism, or
even Benthamism. But if you want men who seek, reasonably and prudently, to
reconcile the best in the wisdom of our ancestors with the change which is
essential to a vigorous civil social existence, then you will do well to turn
to conservative principles. Particular remedies and plans of action are subjects