From collection Ludwig von Mises Collection

Page 1

Page 2
Search
results in pages
Metadata
Today in Washington Newspaper Clipping, March 27, 1945
TODAY IN WASHINGTON
27, III , 1945
By David Lawrence
Totalitarian Doctrine Seen Embodied in Man-power Bill.
Washington, March -Fascism abroad, which is
a war plant. Such a position would be consistent
partnership between capitalistic interests and the
if the Government managed all the war plants and
state, has regimented workers and forced them to
there were no private profits involved. The logical
work for the private profit of management. That
sequel of the situation created by the new man-
same totalitarian doctrine has been embodied in the
power bill would be to abolish all profits and put
new man-power bill which has come from a confer-
all governmental and non-governmental activities
ence committee of members of the House and Senate.
under complete governmental control so that there
If passed, this bill means that workers in America
would not be a single dollar of profit made out of
will lose their right to quit work and that they must
the use of patriotism to force workers to stay. on
take jobs the Government gives them and work for
their jobs. Maybe organized labor will soon begin
designated employers.
to press for such legislation.
The theory back of the much-talked-of universal
Opponents of democracy will derive considerable
service is not being applied. When a man is ordered
satisfaction out of what is happening. Hitler and
into military service, he gets $50 a month and no-
the Nazis may well smile at the spectacle of
body makes any profit out of his service to his
democracy, which calls itself free, finding that it
country. But now the Government, claiming it is
cannot organize itself on a voluntary basis to win
fulfilling a war purpose, orders American workers
the war but must threaten jail sentences to get
to serve private employers who make profits. If the
the war production job done. Hitler is losing the
workers refuse they are subject to jail penalties.
war but apparently his philosophy is winning.
This strange development has been fostered by a
Will the Senate and House acquiesce as did the
small group of universal service advocates who think
Reichstag in Nazi Germany and as have parliamen
they can spare the profit system from similar treat-
tary bodies also at other great moments in history
ment. Instead they will bring the kind of contro-
when the steamroller of military necessity rides
versy that should never have been permitted at this
roughshod over them and demands action? Or will
stage of the war. For the issue of freedom versus
members of Congress stand on their rights and in
involuntary servitude is raised.
sist on a truly voluntary plan?
Senator O'Mahoney of Wyoming, Democrat of the
liberal and progressive school of thought, rightly
The real reason for the man-power muddle has
condemns the proposed legislation as regimentation
been inefficiency in the administration, which now
such as Hitler used and Stalin promulgated to get
seeks a way out by drastic measures that will cover
control of the workers in Germany and Russia, re-
up its mistakes. It is tragic indeed that, as Amer
ican armies are winning a great victory, this democ
spectively. Organized labor has asked the Congress
racy is asked to adopt totalitarian methods. Fas-
to defeat the measure.
The proposed legislation is vicious in that it de-
cism has always been simpler than democracy but
the American people, up to now at least, have pre
prives an aggrieved citizen of any-court appeal. It
ferred the cumbersomeness of democracy to the
offers, to be sure, an administrative or inter-depart-
efficiency of Fascism. If we were losing the war by
mental committee to hear complaints but, under re-
our methods it would be different, but we are win
cent decisions of the courts, there would appear to
ning. The administration's idea of reward evident)
be no possibility of review by the courts of decisions
is to force workers to become part of a strait jacke
made by the bureaus enforcing such legislation.
which deprives them of the oldest right in American
There is certainly no opportunity for relief within
history-freedom to work without state-mai rules
the time limits of the bill.
of enforced work or slavery.
It is fallacious to say that if the Government can
order n man into the Army, it can order him into
Copyright, 1945. AM Rights Reserved.
Viewer Controls
Toggle Page Navigator
P
Toggle Hotspots
H
Toggle Readerview
V
Toggle Search Bar
S
Toggle Viewer Info
I
Toggle Metadata
M
Zoom-In
+
Zoom-Out
-
Re-Center Document
Previous Page
←
Next Page
→
Today in Washington Newspaper Clipping, March 27, 1945
Details
03/27/1945